PEER REVIEW PROCESS

  1. Articles published in Al-Kanza: Journal of Banking and Finance are reviewed by 2 bestary partners.
  2. The journal review applies a double blind review system.
  3. Plagiarism screening of manuscripts submitted to Al-Kanza: Journal of Banking and Finance is carried out by an editorial system and reviewers are also assisted by checking on Turnitin.
  4. In conducting the review, the reviewer considers: novelty of the topic, objectivity, method, impact / scientific implications, conclusions and references. Choose one of the final recommendations, namely:
  • Accept Submission. Accept the article without any revisions given
  • Revision Required. Provide revisions without having to do a re-review. After the author revises the manuscript, proceed directly to the editing process.
  • Resubmit for Review. Provide revisions and after the author revises the manuscript is reviewed again.
  • Resubmit elsewhere: the manuscript is rejected and submitted to another journal.
  • Decline Submission. Rejecting the paper because the quality does not meet the requirements.
  • See comments: revision is needed according to the reviewer's suggestions (in the form of recommendations)
    1. Acceptance of an article by the Editor depends on the novelty of the research, the significance of the article, the correctness of the content, the level of originality, the clarity of the description, and the suitability for the purpose of the journal.